Two wins, then a debate about the encore
RESCENE's week began with a milestone and turned into a debate about how they sound without a backing track. On 10 November the group took first place on The Show with 'With', the title track from their fourth mini-album PULSE. The following day they claimed the top spot on Show Champion, giving them two music show wins in two days, a double crown that Koreaboo reported alongside the reaction to the encore stage that followed the first win.
The live encore vocals became the focus. Criticism centred on unstable pitch and vocal volume from some members. Online communities argued that a professional singer should be able to hold a tune when the performance is pared back, and fans expressed disappointment that pitch problems were noticeable in an encore, where there is no choreography to manage. Others defended the group, pointing out that some members sang relatively steadily and that judging an entire group's ability on a few moments was excessive.
The encore follows a win on a Korean music show, and it is usually the point where the winning act performs again without the full staging of the competition. That is why the focus falls so squarely on voices, and why a short clip can travel further than the broadcast itself.
Minami's message to fans
On 11 November, Minami posted a message to fans on a fan communication platform. According to Koreaboo, she thanked fans and said, 'We still have a lot to improve on.' She also wrote, 'We hardly sleep more than an hour each day,' and explained that after filming music broadcasts the group do not rest immediately but continue with other shoots and rehearsals.
She thanked her fellow members for their hard work and said that without fans' encouragement the group would not have been able to keep going so far. She promised to work even harder.
The message did not mention the encore or the criticism directly. Koreaboo describes it as drawing attention amid the debate, and reading it as a reply to the controversy is an interpretation rather than a confirmed intention.
What the wording does and does not settle
What Minami's comments do establish is narrower than a full response. She acknowledges that the group has room to improve. She describes a schedule in which filming is followed by other work, and she frames the members' effort and fans' support as reasons the group has continued. She does not say that tiredness caused the vocal problems, and the source does not establish that link. Nor does she set out any specific training plan or promise about future live performances beyond working harder.
The wording is collective. Minami says 'we', not 'I', and the message does not single out any member or confirm which voices were being discussed. That reads as a group-level acknowledgement rather than a ranking of individual singers, which matters when the criticism was uneven and some members were described as relatively steady. It also leaves the specifics of any improvement work unstated, so listeners are left with a stated intention rather than a detailed plan.
The rise that made the encore matter
RESCENE's rise helps explain why the encore attracted so much attention. The group debuted in 2024 and gained wider recognition through the sleeper hit 'LOVE ATTACK'. PULSE arrived on 3 November and surpassed 600,000 copies in initial sales, breaking the group's own record. 'With' has also performed well on music charts, and the two broadcast wins confirmed the momentum. Koreaboo reported the figures and the chart performance as part of the same story.
A bigger audience brings more eyes to every stage, including the ones that are not choreographed. The encore is a byproduct of winning, but it is also one of the few moments when a music show performance is reduced to voices. For a group in the middle of a breakthrough, that combination makes a short clip carry more weight than it might for an act with a longer record behind it.
A three-night concert is the next real test
The next significant date is not another music show but a concert. RESCENE are scheduled to hold their first solo concert from 19 to 21 February next year at the Olympic Hall in Seoul's Olympic Park. A three-night run at that venue is a step up in scale, and it sets a different kind of challenge from an encore.
A concert asks for sustained singing across a full set, with fewer opportunities to rely on the production around a single broadcast performance. That does not mean the February shows will settle the argument about the encore, and nothing in the source suggests the group are treating them that way. It does mean there is a clear, announced occasion when listeners will hear more of RESCENE's live singing than a short clip provides.
Why the fan reaction remains split
The fan reaction has stayed split because the two sides are answering different questions. One side is asking whether the encore met a professional standard. The other is asking whether a few moments are a fair sample of a group's ability, especially when some members performed steadily. Both questions matter, and neither is settled by the other.
There is also a difference between criticism of a performance and criticism of a group's potential. The first can be specific and useful; the second is harder to prove from an encore clip. RESCENE have not issued a detailed statement about the technical side of the performance, and the source does not include one. What they have is a member's acknowledgement that improvement is needed, set against a record of commercial success that shows the audience is growing.
The takeaway
The wins stand. The initial sales record stands. The concert dates stand. The encore debate sits alongside those facts rather than cancelling them, and Minami's message is the clearest indication so far of how the group want to be seen: grateful, aware of the gap between where they are and where they want to be, and asking for continued support while they work on it.
The useful test is not whether one clip was perfect. It is whether the next live stages show progress. Until then, the story is a reminder that a breakthrough week can produce a trophy and a scrutiny cycle at the same time.



